An inside joke created by Conor Lynch and Rob Logan as a response to Rob Logan's father, Butch Logan
The joke came to fruition when Butch began taking up drums in Guitar Hero: World Tour. His constant mistakes (including hitting the bottom of the cymbals and dropping the drumstick) would often cause Butch to scream profanity and rage quit.
One day, Rob and Conor were playing Guitar Hero: World Tour, when Butch walked into the room to watch.
Butch: "Hey guys, what are you playing?"
Rob: Not Band Hero!"
half way through the song, Conor Lynch dropped his drum stick and exclaimed, "Goddammit pause the game Logan I pulled a Butch!" Rob immediately paused that game and Butch could only exclaim "Hey!" and left.